Rivers SOS members honoured with Australia Day awards

Julie Sheppard, Secretary of the Rivers SOS Alliance and Macarthur National Parks Association activist, and Robin Craig, Rivers SOS and animal rights activist, have been presented Australia Day awards by Wollondilly Council.

This is welcome recognition for their work for Rivers SOS in the Southern Coalfield. Wollondilly Council has been consistently supportive in spite of coal mines and miners in this area.

Posted in News | Leave a comment

Submissions needed on Coal and Gas Strategy

The NSW Department of Planning is writing the Coal and Gas Strategy for the state [link]. It’s essential that public comment highlights the need to protect rivers (and people!) from the effects of coal and coal seam gas mining.

For some background, you can read the scoping paper [link].

The closing date for public feedback is Friday, 15 April 2010. In your submission, make sure you address the terms of reference [link].

Submissions should be sent to:

coalandgasstrategy@planning.nsw.gov.au

Coal and Gas Strategy
Department of Planning
GPO Box 39 SYDNEY NSW 2001

Posted in Actions | Leave a comment

Survey reveals Hunter’s sick rivers

ABC Online
1 Feb 2011

A survey of the Hunter’s waterways has revealed the health of some is so poor they could be at risk of dying completely.

The Catchment Management Authority’s recent Waterwatch Survey recorded high phosphorus levels at two-thirds of the 200 rivers and creeks that were monitored in the Upper and Lower Hunter.

At some sites the readings were so high, there is concern the waterways could be strangled by aquatic weed infestations or seriously affected by algal blooms.

Waterwatch Co-ordinator, Amanda Gregory says people need to be careful they do not make the problem worse.

“I guess the whole community is exacerbating the problem,” she said.

“There’s even small actions that people take like not picking up their dog poo, actually affects the amount of phosphorus in the water.

“There’s also illegal discharge and stormwater pollution as well as farming that can be causing the problem.”

Ms Gregory says the current warm weather could trigger problems for the waterways.

“With the warmer weather and high nutrient levels, that’s a perfect environment for algal blooms and aquatic weed blooms which basically can strangle waterways and then cause the oxygen levels to decrease as they die.

“So basically you end up with dead waterways.”

Posted in Newspaper articles or other media | Leave a comment

NSW opposition lets miners write lands policy

Sydney Morning Herald
Jan 20, 2011

THE state opposition has allowed the mining industry to rewrite parts of its regional land use policy, deleting commitments to toughen regulatory compliance on miners, leaked documents reveal.

The Liberals and Nationals also handed their draft policy to the NSW Farmers Association to amend – but only after changes made by the NSW Minerals Council were included in the document.

Two draft versions of the land use policy passed to the Herald show the minerals council insisted certain anti-mining lines be removed.

Advertisement: Story continues below

A draft Coalition commitment to ”improve monitoring and compliance” for any mining project on agricultural land was twice deleted from the ”strategic regional land use planning policy” document. The line does not appear in a later policy document given to the farmers association for comment.

The manipulation of election policy by miners is bound to call into question Barry O’Farrell’s recent conversion to conservation and the environment. Less than a fortnight ago the Opposition Leader said he would create a new national park south of Sydney if he wins office in March.

It will also stir bad blood between miners and farmers in resource-rich areas of NSW where landowners, particularly in areas like the Liverpool Plains, are concerned about the rapid growth of coal and coal seam gas projects and exploration.

Mistrust between farmers and miners has even descended into industry whispers about why the opposition industry spokesman, Duncan Gay, snubbed the farmers association’s Christmas drinks last month but attended the minerals council’s soiree.

The documents show the miners are desperate to play down tensions, asking for the removal of a reference to growth in the industry as increasing ”land use conflict”. The council changed that to ”seeing expansion of these industries on to high value agriculture land”.

The council also asked for any reference to ”water resources” and the potential impacts of mining on them to be removed, preferring the term ”precious environmental assets”.

Miners have had to defend coal seam gas extraction, which can damage water tables particularly when the so-called ”fracking” or rock fracturing technique is used.

The document reveals plans by the Coalition to establish an office of agricultural sustainability and food security, reporting directly to the premier. Farmers have been calling for the office and a halt to all mining projects until detailed assessment of land use is conducted by a new government.

The minerals council is against the idea, noting that it hadn’t been ”fully thought through, including how the office will be funded, role and function of the office etc”.

The Coalition, if it won office, would announce a ”transitional period” in which tougher assessment criteria would be applied to mining projects on agricultural land, including a ”pause” on granting new mining titles. About 70 per cent of NSW is now under mineral and petroleum title or application.

The council advises against any pause, saying it should be ”made more transparent and the community will be given a say”.

The Coalition would also move to introduce aquifer interference regulation in a bid to protect agricultural water supplies.

A senior government source said it was ”extraordinary” to allow pressure groups to actively rewrite election policies. ”I’ve never heard of this before,” the source said.

Mr Gay said it was not unusual to ”consult widely” on policies. ”Our final policy will show that we are not beholden to either miners or farmers,” he said.

A spokesman for the minerals council chief executive, Nicole Williams, said miners had been working ”side-by-side” with farmers on the policy. ”Both bodies have provided comments and feedback on innumerable versions of this draft policy,” he said.

The farmers association president, Charles Armstrong, said he was confident that the final Coalition policy would reflect farmers’ concerns.

“The NSW Farmers Association is still negotiating matters relating to mining policies with the NSW opposition,” he said.

”We are confident our policies will be reflected in their policy document.”

Posted in Newspaper articles or other media | Leave a comment

NOW’s Preliminary Report on the drying up of World Heritage Thirlmere Lakes

MEDIA RELEASE , from THE RIVERS SOS ALLIANCE

Rivers SOS is disappointed in the report from NSW Office of Water. Their findings are summarised in the attached media release, which also gives the link to the 80-page report itself.

We feel there has been a too-hasty attempt to publish something, however inadequate, to adress the concerns of so many locals and others who love these lakes, which are/were the most beautiful part of the World Heritage listed Blue Mountains National Park ,but have been drying up for the past few years.

Though this is entitled a “preliminary” report we suspect that there is an intention to bury the troublesome issue before the March election – we doubt that a full report will be completed before then, meanwhile this document absolves longwall mining from any blame. Once again the drought is blamed.

However in this Warragamba Catchment the drought was broken over two years ago, in 2008. Rivers SOS waited through a year of heavy rain before we felt we could conclude that longwall mining may be a cause of the drying up of the lakes.

In past droughts records show that the lakes refilled rapidly after rain, but this has not happened. Local people who frequent the lakes remark that they have been slowly drying out since longwall mines went 700m away, while 4 megalitres of water per day are pumped out from the mines, no doubt depleting the ground water which has fed the lakes for 15 million years.

Moreover independent mining experts hold similar opinions to ours – see comments from Professor Philip Pells below.

Professor Pells is happy for the media to publish his comments and his phone number is 43847055.

Previously we sent you a short analysis of how mining may have fractured the aquifers, from a paper given by retired professor Dr Brian Marshall. He was also happy for this to be published. His phone number is 47841148, m: 0403804994.

Both Pells and Marshall have long experience in mine subsidence and geology and hold or have held senior academic positions.

Water Minister Phil Costa promised Rivers SOS members in December that he would get together a round table of experts from his department plus interested experts from outside, such as Pells and Marshall, to discuss the disappearing Thirlmere Lakes. We would appreciate it if the media could ask the Minister when this might take place.

Professor Pells’ comments are as follows, in response to a request from Caroline Graham of Rivers SOS:-

Caroline,

I am on holiday till the 11th so have had to read the 80 page report “Thirlmere Lakes Groundwater Study” on my iPhone- no mean feat!

The report has a lot of generalized geological and hydrogeological data that is of little relevance to the Thirlmere Lakes. However, it does contain some interesting data from the Dpts groundwater monitoring bores(regional) and from Xstrata’s monitoring bores. These will warrant careful study.

What I can say at present is :

1 the assessment of the geological regime beneath the lakes is poor. There is no interpreted profile down to seam level, no mention of the Bald Hill Claystone, and no analysis of the Holocene sediments beneath the lakes.
2. The analyses of groundwater changes associated with the longwalls is so simplistic as to be incorrect.
3. The analyses of rainfall records is simplistic in that there is no quantification of the post-2000 drought relative to earlier droughts for which there is some information as to lake behavior.
4. The data from Xstrata’s monitoring bores is of questionable relevance given that they are all well to the NE and E of the longwalls that could have impacted on the lakes
5. No effort appears to have been made to collect and collate information as to historical lake levels.

Overall I can only conclude that the NSW Government has jumped the gun in tracing a conclusion as to the reasons why the lakes seem to have remained dry when the drought has well and truly broken. Just possibly, the conclusions of the report could be correct- but, I think that would be more a matter of luck than good science.

I will take some time to collect, collate and properly analyse all relevant hydrological, anecdotal, groundwater, geological, monitoring, and mining data. Only then will it be possible to reach robust scientific conclusions,

You may quote me, as you wish.

Regards

Philip Pells

Posted in News | 2 Comments

Lock the Gate alliance national event – Tara, QLD, 1-5 May

Massive coal seam gas projects in the Darling Downs have received government approvals, but not community approval. Rural landholders are now holding them off at their front gates and now is the time to show them that they have your support.

When: 1-5 May 2011
Where: Tara Showgrounds (300km west of Brisbane)
What: 4 days of workshops, forums, displays and direct action
How: to register your interest or for more details,

Email tara2011@lockthegate.org.au or phone 07 4669 4864

The Lock the Gate movement has gone national and this national movement against coal and coal seam gas mining as well as farmers and environmental groups around the state and country are backing a four-day event including displays, workshops and direct action, at Tara on the western Darling Downs in Queensland. Local organisers the Western Downs Alliance are engaged in a confrontation with the British Gas-owned QGC that intends to establish a gas field early 2011 on the Tara rural residential estates, home to more than 2,000 people.

Farmers, environmentalists and scientists have been warning the State and federal governments for some time that CSG activities are potentially hazardous to human health, agricultural land and underground water and could damage the Great Artesian Basin for centuries. They have called on these governments to impose a moratorium on the industry until all outstanding social and environmental issues have been addressed. Their only response has been to give the companies the go-ahead to bulldoze their way onto people’s properties and conduct an uncontrolled experiment on the Australian environment, meanwhile crossing their fingers that nothing disastrous happens – at least while they are in office.

Tara 2011 will be based at the Tara Showground and supporters are urged to gather showing the widespread popular concern. Bring lightweight campaign gear, everything else catered for. Remember, the coal seam gas industry has plans to move into many, many parts of Australia, so while this is happening on the Western Downs, it could be happening in your area tomorrow.

Posted in Events | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Not enough known on CSG: experts

Queensland Country Life
8 Jan 2011

FEDERAL and State water experts are backing calls by landholders for an urgent study of the potential impacts of coal seam gas (CSG) development on the nation’s water resources.

The focus is largely on the potential $35 billion industry in south-east Queensland, where up to 40,000 wells could dot the Surat and Bowen Basins over the next 20 years – and where there have already been water contamination incidents.

Last month, Arrow Energy confirmed benzene, toluene, ethylene and xylene – together known as BTEX – had been found in wells at a Bowen Basin gas site.

In October, BTEX was discovered in eight wells at drill sites run by Origin Energy about 300 kilometres west of Brisbane, while earlier this year a coal gas project near Kingaroy was shut down when benzene and toluene were detected.

While 95 per cent of known reserves are in Queensland, increasing exploration in NSW by companies, including Santos and Metgasco, is expected to uncover more reserves.

Companies are testing for CSG using hydraulic fracturing, known as “fracking”.

Rules regulating this practice, which involves injecting a mix of water, sand and chemicals underground to force gas to the surface, are not clear cut, as specific approval for fracking is not required.

NSW Natural Resources Commissioner, John Williams, has warned there could be potentially catastrophic impacts on State water resources if CSG projects go ahead unchecked.

He supported a call by National Water Commissioner, Chloe Munroe, for a precautionary approach.

The National Water Commission released a position paper earlier this month identifying a variety of risks, saying cumulative impacts were not well understood, and that there could be “substantial consequences”.

“If not adequately managed and regulated, the industry risks significant, long-term and adverse impacts on surface and ground-water systems,” Ms Munroe said.

She said mining should operate under the same rules applied to other water users.

Dr Williams said it was vital that mining and natural resources were integrated before mining activity occurred.

“We need a plan of action to minimise harm to water resources if coal seam gas extraction takes place,” he said.

“We do need to mine, but we need to know where we can do it without harming natural resources, and the best time to do this work is before the development happens so the community knows where it can be harvested without damaging their future and the mining industry has some security.”

He said legislation, including the Mining Act, needed to be brought into line with sustainable development principles.

Dr Williams, a member of the Wentworth Group, said taking CSG should not interfere with the viability of water resources and agricultural land, but there was no process yet to prevent this.

Ms Munroe’s report said extracting large volumes of low-quality water would have an impact on connected surface and groundwater systems.

Dramatic depressurisation of coal seams could reduce pressure to nearby aquifers, reducing flows and causing land subsidence.

A report by JP Morgan said the coal gas seam industry had significant water risks, including a reduction in the water supply to towns and landowners, reduced quality, gas migration to water bores and the safe storage of salt.

Posted in Newspaper articles or other media | Leave a comment

O’Farrell shuts out mining colossus from Sydney’s water catchment – SMH

 Ben Cubby and Sean Nicholls

Sydney Morning Herald January 8, 2011

THOUSANDS of hectares of pristine wilderness on the edge of south-western Sydney, fought over by mining and environment interests for decades, will be saved and opened to the public as a national park if the NSW Coalition wins government in March.

But the announcement, to be made today by the Opposition Leader, Barry O’Farrell, sets up a potential conflict with BHP Billiton, which still holds the right to mine the billions of dollars worth of coal in the area.

The park, based on the Dharawal State Conservation Area, would add about 6200 hectares of bushland to the public estate, and add one of the final pieces to the jigsaw of protected wilderness areas around Sydney.

It is one of the last remaining areas of intact natural bushland near the city, and sits between the Royal National Park and the Blue Mountains World Heritage Area.

Mr O’Farrell said ”no deal has been done” with the mining company, which revised plans to mine under the conservation area in October but retains the right to apply again over the 30-year life of its lease.

Mr O’Farrell, who hiked in the area yesterday with the shadow environment minister, Catherine Cusack, acknowledged the Coalition would need to enter into discussions about potential compensation. Continue reading

Posted in News, Newspaper articles or other media | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Green light for Duralie mine plan 27 Dec, 2010

BY MATTHEW KELLY ENVIRONMENT REPORTER

THE federal government has approved the controversial expansion of the Duralie open-cut mine.This is despite protests about its potential environmental impact on the Gloucester Valley.

The Department of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities approved the project with conditions on December 22.

The mine’s production will now rise from 12.3 million tonnes to 20 million tonnes, with maximum annual output rising from 1.8 million tonnes to 3 million tonnes.

The project, which has already been approved by the state government, was referred for assessment under the Commonwealth Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation in May.

Environmentalists raised concerns about the potential for increased saline run-off from the mine on the giant barred frog, which is found around the Mammy Johnsons River.

Concerns were also raised about the project’s impact on the habitat of the swift parrot.

Conditions of the approval state that the drilling activities associated with the expansion must not occur within areas of known or potential giant barred frog habitat.

The mine must also conduct baseline frog surveys prior to conducting irrigation activities.

Within a year of the project, the mine must permanently protect and secure an environmental offset area to compensate for disturbance to the habitat of the frog and parrot.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Posted in Newspaper articles or other media | Leave a comment

A black day: Duralie Coal approval given

It is a black day for our valleys and our creeks and the river systems of Wards River, Mammy Johnsons River, Karuah River to Port Stephens/Marine Park.

The NSW Planning Department’s final approval decision has been granted for Duralie Coal to proceed. The NSW Planning Department has also approved the two Stratford Coal applications.

Rivers SOS president Amanda Albury contacted the Commonwealth Government Department regarding their determination (EPBC 2010/5296) on Duralie Coal and the EPBC Act (Giant Barred Frog and Swift Parrot). The response was that the Commonwealth Government has given Duralie Coal approval to proceed with conditions until 2020.

Two creeks have already been destroyed by Duralie Coal: Coal Shaft Creek (in the mining area) and No Name Creek (in the exploration area).

At this sad time, Amanda and fellow Rivers SOS member Jenny Thomson would like to thank everyone who gave assistance in opposing the approval:

Jenny and I are very grateful for the people we have met both in person and across the email lists & phone, who have taken the time out in their busy areas they are defending for the environment in stopping to give us assistance. People networking together: congratulations! We have all shown the Government that there are many people who object to their wrongful approvals they are handing out to mining companies.

The area is under attack not only from Gloucester Resources, but now other companies seeking to take up residence in the valley: Thunderbolts Gold, the 4 category mine at Girvan (The Branch), Karuah Gravel mine removing the mountain range, and the petroleum/gas yellow aeroplane surveying the area.

The new year will be a time to freshly strategise for the next round, whatever that may be.

Posted in News | Leave a comment